The book by a spy that the government did evejudgesrything to stop --[Reported by Umva mag]

Spycatcher was, it's safe to say, controversial.

Oct 13, 2024 - 08:21
The book by a spy that the government did evejudgesrything to stop --[Reported by Umva mag]
A composite image shows Margaret Thatcher, Peter Wright and Wrights memoir, Spycatcher.
From state secrets to accusations of underhandedness, Spycatcher didn’t exactly give MI5 the best rep (Picture: PA/Getty)

A book by a retired British counter-intelligence agent on how he helped unmask a Soviet mole in MI5 sounds like an instant best-seller.

Well, it was in the US at least. Spycatcher, published in 1987, had been banned from being sold in the UK after legal action by the British government.

Courts even blocked newspapers from covering the memoirs, contending that its author, Peter Wright, violated the Official Secrets Act.

Magaret Thatcher, the then-prime minster, had been especially desperate to stop people from reading Spycatcher.

‘I am utterly shattered by the revelations in the book. The consequences of publication would be enormous,’ Thatcher scrawled on a briefing note, as unclassified files would later reveal.

But 36 years ago, the UK government lost a major legal battle that paved the way for Wright’s book to finally be read by millions of Britons.

(FILES) British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher acknowledges applauds on Ocotber 13, 1989 at the end of the Conservative Party conference in Blackpool. At left Foreign Secretary John Major and at right Home Secretary John Hurt. Margaret Thatcher remains despised by many on the left of British politics, but the main Labour opposition seems comfortable citing her as it woos the right before this year's election. Labour leader Keir Starmer and senior colleagues have recently referenced the Conservative icon, highlighting the party's shift to the centre since Starmer succeeded left-winger Jeremy Corbyn. In December 2023, Starmer described Thatcher as effecting
Margaret Thatcher read the unpublished manuscript of Spycatcher in 1986 (Picture: AFP or licensors)

Spycatcher was, it’s safe to say, controversial.

Wright had served in MI5, the UK spy agency, for more than two decades before he retired in 1978 and moved to Australia.

His memoirs accused MI5 officials of all kinds of skulduggery; plotting against fellow spies, defaming the former prime minister Harold Wilson and top agents being communists.

All claims were largely discredited by the government but, at the time, fuelled speculation and criticism about MI5’s activity. After all, the government had long denied M15 even existed, despite the agency being founded in 1909.

The government did not want the book as anyone’s summer holiday read. Ministers succeded in blocking Spycatcher’s publication in the UK (though technically not in Scotland, as it has a separate legal system) in 1985.

Newspapers were handed gag orders – violating them would see journalists tired for contempt of court. Libraries were told stocking Spycatcher would similarly land them in legal hot water.

Wartime powers were employed to stop people from effectively smuggling the book into the UK. Trade and industry secretary Lord Young of Graffham warned the government that: ‘The use of these powers in the Spycatcher case could well be challenged.

The launch of the 'Spycatcher Trail' book by Malcolm Turnbull.Peter Wright and Malcolm Turnbull. Malcolm Turnbull, Peter Wright and Gough Whitlam.Peter Wright, Malcolm Turnbull. . . old spy, wonder boy. September 07, 1988. (Photo by David Porter/Fairfax Media via Getty Images).
Peter Wright (left) and Malcolm Turnbull at the launch event of Spycatcher in 1988 (Picture: Fairfax Media Archive)

‘I am also advised that, even if the book were banned, it would not in practice be possible to catch all copies of the book brought in from the United States either by mail or by individual travellers.’

Indeed, there was no trouble flogging the book across the pond given the First Amendment right to free speech; Spycatcher had sold 400,000 copies by late 1987.

And the government’s woes weren’t over yet. Officials took Wright to court in a bid to prevent his book from being sold in Australia only to be struck down – Downing Street then took its appeal to Australia’s highest court.

As Spycatcher was sold in Scotland, and Scottish papers were able to ‘substantially’ cover the UK’s legal proceedings in Australia, Thatcher’s private secretary Nigel Wicks worried how this situation looked to outsiders.

‘There is therefore much talk in the press about one law for the English, another for the Scots etc,’ Wicks said in a released document.

House of Commons Speaker Bernard Weatherill faced pressure from Solicitor General Sir Nicholas Lyell to ban MPs from discussing the contents of the Spycatcher.

EMBARGOED TO 0001 FRIDAY DECEMBER 29 File photo dated 10/7/1987 of the front cover of the book
Spycatcher had been banned in the UK, but a loophole meant it could be sold in Scotland (Picture: PA)

‘The speaker expressed concern about the “credibility” of his position given that “practically everyone he met” had already read the book,’ Sir Nicholas said.

‘I replied that most people in the country had not read the book and that every newspaper, bookshop and library was at risk of contempt proceedings if they published extracts, quoted from, or sold or stocked the book.’

In the end, however, in 1987, the government lost its desperate fight to prevent Spycatcher from being sold in Australia.

On October 13, 1988, Law Lords, who carried out the judicial functions of the House of Lords, at first seemingly handed the government a win when ruling over whether or not ministers could bar the press from reporting on Spycatcher.

Judges ruled that Wright’s text constituted a serious breach of confidentiality, given he wrote about the comings and goings of the nation’s secret service.

They condemned the author as a traitor but found the government violated freedom of speech because of gagging orders against the Observer and the Guardian.

They said that the press could publish extracts from Spycatcher – the damage to MI5’s reputation was already done as Spycatcher was freely available abroad.

Spycatcher Peter Wright at Hobart Airport on Thursday. October 24, 1987. (Photo by Peter Kevin Solness/Fairfax Media via Getty Images).
Wright died in 1995 (Picture: Fairfax Media Archive)

‘At long last our democratic system has reached the obvious conclusion that these were genuine matters of public importance that the public should be allowed to know about,’ said Donald Trelford, the editor of The Observer, outside court.

A secret note slipped to Tory MPs only a month after the ruling said that the Security Service Act, which for the first time saw the government MI15 existed, was introduced to ‘bolster public confidence and support’ in the secret intelligence agency.

Part of the ruling, however, barred Wright from cashing in royalties from sales of the book in the UK.

Yet the writer died a millionaire aged 78 on April 26, 1995, thanks to international sales of Spycatcher.

‘No British intelligence officer other than Kim Philby caused more mayhem within Britain’s secret services and more trouble for British politicians,’ an obituary in The Independent newspaper wrote, ‘than Peter Wright.’

Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at [email protected].

For more stories like this, check our news page.




The following news has been carefully analyzed, curated, and compiled by Umva Mag from a diverse range of people, sources, and reputable platforms. Our editorial team strives to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the information we provide. By combining insights from multiple perspectives, we aim to offer a well-rounded and comprehensive understanding of the events and stories that shape our world. Umva Mag values transparency, accountability, and journalistic integrity, ensuring that each piece of content is delivered with the utmost professionalism.